How do you respond to the comments of the reviewers?

How do you respond to the comments of the reviewers?

Response: Agree. I/We have, accordingly, done/revised/changed/modified…..to emphasize this point. [Discuss the changes made, providing the necessary explanation/clarification. Mention exactly where in the revised manuscript this change can be found – page number, paragraph, and line.]

Can a paper be rejected after major revision?

Answer: The acceptance rate of a revised paper varies across journals and fields. Additionally, it is not possible to predict the fate of a paper based on the acceptance rates for a specific journal. You have received one recommendation for major and one for minor revisions.

What does major revision mean?

In my field (chemistry), the practice is: for those journals that make a clear distinction between minor and major revision requests, “major revision” means that the paper will have to undergo further review after revision, usually by the same referees, while “minor revision” means that while changes should be made, no …

Is revise and resubmit good?

Authors should view an invitation to revise and resubmit as good news because it means the journal has found value with the article. If authors make a considered effort to address reviewers’ comments, then in all proba- bility, the resubmitted article will be accepted for publication.

How do you put revise and resubmit on resume?

Generally, when I have a paper that is just submitted, I put it on my CV and indicate “under review” and do NOT name the journal. If it has received a revise and resubmit, I put it on my CV as “invited revision” and do put the name of the journal there too. If its in revision, put the journal name.

How do you revise and resubmit?

An overview of the steps for revising and resubmitting your work, along with key pieces of advice from each Associate Editor, is provided below.

1. Step 1: Celebrate a little!
2. Step 2: Read the reviews.
3. Step 3: Revise the manuscript, and write the point-by-point response letter.
4. Step 4: Do not ignore feedback.

What is the difference between minor and major revision?

Most commonly: “Minor Revision” implies that publication is desirable and a limited number of changes will bring the manuscript up to scratch. “Major Revision” implies that the manuscript needs considerable reworking prior to reconsideration.

What is substantial revision?

What is substantial revision? Substantial revision means that you not only re-wrote something, but had to “re-think” it. Most dramatically, you may have realized that you wanted to write about a different topic. Then you’d have to re-think the whole paper.

What is minor revision?

Loading when this answer was accepted… Minor revision usually implies that the reviewers (and the editor) think that authors can correct the paper in a way that will address all of the concerns, and the reviewers not need to see the paper again before publication.

What does moderate revision mean?

Moderate revision Your article has a good chance of being accepted, but requires additional changes to be made to satisfy our reviewers. These changes usually require more time and it is likely we will need to send the revised article back to at least one of the reviewers.

What does it mean required reviews completed?

Answer: When the status shows “Required reviews completed,” it means that the reviews have come in. While it is generally uncommon for the peer review to be completed within 6 days, since this is a revised manuscript, the reviewers were probably already familiar with it, so they could review it within a short time.

What does reviewer invited mean?

Answer: The status “reviewer invited” implies that your manuscript has cleared the initial screening and your paper will be sent for peer review. The journal editor has possibly identified and sent out invitations to potential reviewers for your paper and is waiting for their response.

What is Journal first decision?

Time to First Decision: From submission to first decision, the journal aims to provide authors with a quick decision. Reviewers are given a tight deadline to review the manuscript. Time to Publication: Once an article is accepted, the files are immediately provided to the production department for processing.

How long is the peer review process?

These figures differ between accepted and rejected manuscripts, with first response time of rejected manuscripts taking, on average, 4 weeks longer. While writing a peer review may take between 4 and 8 h, in only 19% of all reported cases authors were informed about the outcome in less than a month.

How much does it cost to publish in Elsevier?

Elsevier’s APC prices are set on a per journal basis, fees range between c$150 and c$9900 US Dollars, excluding tax, with prices clearly displayed on our APC price list and on journal homepages.

Is Elsevier a predatory Journal?

blog » Elsevier now officially a “predatory” publisher.

Is Hindawi predatory?

An interesting example is Hindawi, an Egyptian publisher once considered predatory that improved its practices and standards over time. Beall also lists common practices indicative of low-quality but not necessarily predatory journals.

What happens if you publish in a predatory Journal?

Summary. As a scholar, your legacy will be your publications and you want your papers to be published in high quality journals. If you publish in predatory journals you are unlikely to get recognition by your peers and you may even damage your reputation.

How do you deal with predatory journals?

If your paper is published online by a predatory journal, you may write to the office of the predatory journal and ask them to withdraw the paper from their website.

How many predatory journals are there?

Predatory journals have rapidly increased their publication volumes from 53,000 in 2010 to an estimated 420,000 articles in 2014, published by around 8,000 active journals.