How do you review a scientific paper?

Be upfront and honest with the authors and the editor about which scientific aspects you will focus on in your review. After the first reading, attempt to ‘mirror’ the article by writing down, in detail, your understanding of the science.

How do you thank a reviewer?

How to Respond to Positive Reviews

Thank the Reviewer. The reviewer just said something nice about your company—it would be poor manners if you didn’t thank them!
Respond Quickly To Positive Reviews.
Keep It Short.
Be Authentic and Personal.
Invite Them To Take Action.
Share The Positive Review.

How do you respond to reviewers?

Provide a “yes” or “no” answer whenever possible. When the reviewer is correct, state so in your response. Your goal is to show the reviewer that you took their comments seriously, and you should quickly convey what you did in response to their critique.

How do you revise a research paper and response to reviewers?

Revising your paper and responding to reviewer comments

Address all points raised by the editor and reviewers.
Describe the revisions to your manuscript in your response letter.
Perform any additional experiments or analyses the reviewers recommend (unless you feel that they would not make your paper better; if this is the case, explain why in your response letter)

How do I disagree with reviewers?

You can always defend your manuscript and write to the reviewer(s). Elaborating on your idea supporting it with strong evidence and rationale help reviewers reconsider and approve your manuscript. Be polite, give proper argument to explain why you differ with reviewer comment, and let the editor decide.

How do you respond to peer review comments when submitting papers?

Respond with “yes” or “thank you for the comment” without providing clear details of your response to the query and the changes you have made to the manuscript as a result.

How do you respond to referees comments when submitting manuscripts for publication?

A structured layout for responding to referees’ comments is suggested that includes the 3 golden rules: (1) respond completely; (2) respond politely; and (3) respond with evidence.

How do you reply to referees comments?

The 3 golden rules of structuring your response letter

Rule 1: Answer completely. It important that all of the referees’ comments are responded to in sequence, however irritating or vague they may appear to you.
Rule 2: Answer politely.
Rule 3: Answer with evidence.

How do you respond to referee comments for scientific articles?

It will be reasonable to begin the letter with a sentence like” Thank you for giving me a chance of revising my manuscript.” Your responses should be scientific, and systematic. You may get help from other authors or before sending your reply you may ask other authors to read, and review your manuscript.

How do you respond to a journal acceptance?

I appreciate your acceptance of my paper for publication in the World Journal of Gastroenterology. I thank you for the valuable comments on this paper and have made the following adjustments accordingly. Reviewer #1 The manuscript is quite well written.

How do you write an author response letter?

Make your response letter visually very clear. Answer every request or question, but use no more words than necessary. Be polite, diplomatic, and not defensive: use the “we’re all on the same side” philosophy. Find peers or a mentor to review your author response letter—as well as your paper—before resubmission.

How do you write a rebuttal?

strategies for rebuttal

Point out the flaws [errors] in the counterargument.
Agree with the counterargument but give them a new point/fact that contradicts their argument.
Agree with the other side’s support but twist the facts to suit your argument.

How do you write a rebuttal review?

Include a small paragraph thanking the reviewers for their valuable time and useful contribution. Mention that you appreciate the inputs they have given and that their inputs will definitely help improve your manuscript. Rebuttal letters that thank the referees set a positive tone right from the beginning.

How do you end a rebuttal letter?

Close the Letter Suggestions include, “Respectfully,” “Sincerely,” or “Regards.” Keep a copy of your rebuttal letter for your personal records, as well as subsequent correspondence regarding the matter in question.

What happens in a rebuttal?

In law, rebuttal is a form of evidence that is presented to contradict or nullify other evidence that has been presented by an adverse party. In rebuttal, the rebutting party may generally bring witnesses and evidence which were never before declared, so long as they serve to rebut the prior evidence.

What is rebuttal document?

The rebuttal letter is an author’s chance to directly reply to the reviewers, announce plans to improve the work, clear up misunderstandings or defend aspects of the work. How it is written can make a big difference in whether or not an appeal is granted and how the reviewers judge the revision.

What is another word for rebuttal?

confutation	refutation
counter	vindication
justification	plea
comeback	counter-statement
return	refutal

How do you write a chargeback rebuttal letter?

Chargeback Rebuttal Letter

The chargeback reason code.
The dollar amount that you are contesting (e.g. the entire chargeback amount or a partial amount).
List of all evidence/documentation that you are submitting.
Brief summary of how your evidence invalidates the cardholder’s claim.

How do you win a chargeback as a seller?

These are our tips for increasing your chances of winning a chargeback dispute:

Maintain accurate records and gather compelling evidence. Disputes are usually much less favorable for merchants than they are for customers.
Check the reason code.
Resolve issues through customer service.
React quickly.