Is revise and resubmit good?
Authors should view an invitation to revise and resubmit as good news because it means the journal has found value with the article. If authors make a considered effort to address reviewers’ comments, then in all proba- bility, the resubmitted article will be accepted for publication.
What happens after revise and resubmit?
Revise and resubmit means exactly what it says: if you revise the manuscript and resubmit it, we will look at it again (hopefully with the same editor and reviewers, but not necessarily). Typically this means the required revisions are substantial enough that it will go to reviewers again.
How long should a revise and resubmit take?
about 11 weeks
Can a paper get rejected after a major revision?
Papers having two reviewers’ recommendations to accept and minor revision have much greater chance of acceptance (more than 98%) than papers receiving two reviewers’ recommendations that include a major revision and a reject or two rejections (which results in an acceptance rate of less than 5%): (Figure 1).
Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?
When a paper of mine was first reviewed, one of the reviewers was okay with the paper and the other one requested minor revisions. The journal clearly said that the paper was accepted, subject to minor amendments and even went on to mention tentative publication dates. Now the journal has rejected the paper.
How do you respond to a major revision?
Answer: You should always provide point-by-point responses to the reviewer comments in addition to incorporating the reviewers’ suggestions in your revised manuscript. What this means is that you will have to copy each of the reviewer comments into a word doc followed by your response to that specific comment.
What is the difference between minor and major revision?
Most commonly: “Minor Revision” implies that publication is desirable and a limited number of changes will bring the manuscript up to scratch. “Major Revision” implies that the manuscript needs considerable reworking prior to reconsideration.
What does major revision mean?
In my field (chemistry), the practice is: for those journals that make a clear distinction between minor and major revision requests, “major revision” means that the paper will have to undergo further review after revision, usually by the same referees, while “minor revision” means that while changes should be made, no …
What does substantial revision mean?
Substantial revision means that you not only re-wrote something, but had to “re-think” it. Most dramatically, you may have realized that you wanted to write about a different topic. Then you’d have to re-think the whole paper. But there are other ways of re-thinking and re-seeing your essays.
Why a manuscript is rejected?
For most journals, manuscripts are rejected at one of two steps in the review process. The first level is an editorial rejection. The English is inadequate for peer review. The manuscript is scientifically incomplete and/or lacks a significant, novel contribution to the field.
What is minor revision?
Loading when this answer was accepted… Minor revision usually implies that the reviewers (and the editor) think that authors can correct the paper in a way that will address all of the concerns, and the reviewers not need to see the paper again before publication.
How long does a minor revision take?
about two-three weeks
What is revising a paper?
What does it mean to revise? Revision literally means to “see again,” to look at something from a fresh, critical perspective. It is an ongoing process of rethinking the paper: reconsidering your arguments, reviewing your evidence, refining your purpose, reorganizing your presentation, reviving stale prose.
What does Revision requested mean?
Manuscript Accepted or Revision Requested So, the journal has either accepted your manuscript or requested that you revise it for another round of peer review. In both cases, you should do exactly the same thing: revise your manuscript in accordance with the recommendations of the referees.
What does it mean required reviews completed?
When the status shows “Required reviews completed,” it means that the reviews have come in, but it might not mean that your paper is being evaluated by the editor. Generally, big journals such as Elsevier receive a large number of submissions and the editor has to handle multiple submissions.
What does submission being processed mean?
Usually, at the ‘Submissions Being Processed’ stage, the manuscript is in the process of being transmitted to an editor. Please check your inbox to see whether you have received a confirmation of the successful completion of your submission along with the manuscript number and submission ID.
What does moderate revision mean?
Moderate revision Your article has a good chance of being accepted, but requires additional changes to be made to satisfy our reviewers. These changes usually require more time and it is likely we will need to send the revised article back to at least one of the reviewers.
What is the first decision?
Often, the decision taken by a journal on the manuscript in its original form, that is, before it is revised, is referred to as the “first decision.” The first decision could either be a rejection without peer review or a request to revise and resubmit after peer review. This is often referred to as the final decision.
What does reviewer invited mean?
Answer: The status “reviewer invited” implies that your manuscript has cleared the initial screening and your paper will be sent for peer review. The journal editor has possibly identified and sent out invitations to potential reviewers for your paper and is waiting for their response.
Is application under review a good sign?
If your application makes it this far than it would most likely be labeled “under review” and the next step from here is either to receive an email regarding the interview, or a rejection email. Overall – being under review does not mean something positive or negative. It is a neutral sign.